Jezz, was that a rough tasting, or was it just me? I think we all know now, without a doubt, why it’s affectionately referred to as Firewater. Well let’s get down to business.
There is a clear cut looser. Those of you who were rooting for the hooch, hoping that the cheep underdog would take it, go ahead and put your giant foam fingers away and try to make it to the other teams side before anyone notices. Unlike TAAKA, Ancient Age, is not the little bourbon that could. Sitting at seven mehs, I could lump it into the nothing special category, but with only one like (the only bourbon that only got one like) and six dislikes, it’s pretty clear that most people were not going to rush out to the liquor store and stock up on it. And the one person that did like it, had a couple others that they liked more. So, even if you’re trying to be cheap, and are telling your self, ‘Well I’m going to mix it with coke anyway.’ Go with something else. One person said that even after adding it to coke, it still tasted like dirt. I mean, come on, even KD got more likes.
This next one saddens me a little, but I understand why it’s so low on the list, it is a little harsh. With six dislikes, five mehs, and only three likes, Wild Turkey is just barely ahead of Ancient Age. Most people said that it burned (well, 101 proof will do that). one person commented that it took her breath away and felt like she needed her inhaler. But it is kind of important to note here that Wild Turkey was the last one to be tasted, and by the time everyone got to it they were ready to get onto the mixing and casual drinking. But I’m not making excuses for it… I won’t blame you if you don’t want to try it (but I still like it).
Now for some surprises: tied with five dislikes, four mehs, and five likes are Maker’s Mark and Kentucky Deluxe! WHAT WHAT?!?!? Hold up! These bottles have a price difference of $21.50, and my elite tasting panel of friends is telling me that they are ‘bout the same. Certainly not in flavor, they have two completely different flavor profiles, but in drinkability.
Let’s look at KD first: It was described to have very little flavor but still smooth and enjoyable. Someone even said that it had a vanilla tone to it. Someone else said that it was easy as butter. The thing to keep in mind here is that KD is not bourbon. Bourbon tends to have a bit of a kick to it, a lot of times it will take your breath away (hopefully in a good way) that’s part of what makes it a bourbon. People liked KD because it didn’t have that kick, it was easy to enjoy, especially when put next to some ‘kick you in the face’ bourbons. That being said I would not suggest that you go out and order a KD neat and sip on it. But, like I said earlier, on a budget? Planning on mixing it with coke anyway? Good ‘ol Kentucky Deluxe ain’t a bad choice.
Maker’s Mark… How did you score on the same level as KD? This was actually my first time having Maker’s, so I didn’t know what to expect. Most described it as harsh, but a few picked up on butterscotch tones, a cinnamony-ness, and woody flavors. The people that didn’t like it, didn’t like it. One person simply left a :( on their comment card. So, if you’ve never had it before, should you spend the money on it? That’s a tough one. It’s a good split of people who liked it and didn’t like it. My suggestion, convince someone else to buy a bottle and try some of theirs first. And for the record, the whole wax dipped thing is over rated. Underneath all that red wax is a screw top.
Now we are getting to the good stuff, with three dislikes, four mehs, and six likes we have Knob Creek. Unlike me, most people picked up on the high proof right away, but also caught honey and caramel flavors. So the high proof didn’t take away from the flavor. But, then again, there were some people that only wrote BURRNN!!! on their comment card. I made a peach tea bourbon out of this one and the sweetness of the tea worked really well with the high proof. So if you’re not afraid of higher proof liquors, I’d say give it a try.
Really close in the running with Knob Creek was Jack Daniels. He got two dislikes, seven mehs, and five likes. The mehs have it, making Jack nothing special. But I feel that this rating fits its price range. Again, the people who normally drink Jack liked it but couldn’t say definitively that it was Jack, they just knew that they liked it. The comments for it were incredibly underwhelming. Most were simply I like it, or do not like, or smooth, or yuck, or eh. Nothing to really describe it at all. My conclusion, it’s just Jack. If you already drink and love it, pour another, if not, you’re not missing much.
Drumroll please! We have two winners! Well, they are two completely different bourbons, and the one you prefer will depend on the type of drink you like. So here they are:
Fighting Cock. It’s kinda fitting since this is The Cock’s Tales. This is a funny one, it got seven likes, four mehs, and three dislikes. When describing it, most people proclaimed that they liked the burn. The only way I can describe it is this; you know that feeling you get when you are about to bite into a really sour pickle, and you know it’s going to be sour, and you know you are going to make a face, and you do it anyway, and you keep doing it till you’ve eaten the whole pickle? And even though it was really sour, you’d do it again? Or when you load up a chip with a huge glob of super hot salsa, and you look at your buddies and say to them, ‘this is going to be bad’ and then you eat it and the next thing you know you’re sweating, turning red and slapping your hand on the table going, ‘WooohWee! That’s some good salsa!’ That’s how Fighting Cock is. It defiantly has a kick and can be described as rough, but that’s what people seemed to like about it. Where as some of the other ones were rough and unpleasant, Fighting Cock was like a rollercoaster, rough and unpolished but fun. But if you don’t want a bourbon to kick you in the face, don’t buy it, but if you like a little spice, this one's for you ;)
And with Seven likes, six mehs, and only one dislike we have Corner Creek! See, I knew it would help if people didn’t look at the stupid bottle! It was described and light and smooth, oaky and woody, sweet and easy. On the downside, a lot of people said that it was lacking in flavor, too smooth or too sweet. This is just an easy going bourbon, there is not a lot of hype surrounding it and the makers themselves don’t build it up to ridiculous proportions, they simple set out to make a good bourbon, put a lot of care into it and made something that they are proud of. I’ve never been to the distillery or anything like that, but I like to think of them as just being good ‘ol country folk, not hiding behind wax dipping fiascos or an over hyped name. Even their website is simple and straight forward. So, if you want a easy going, light and friendly bourbon, Corner Creek is the one for you.
I just want to take a moment and talk a bit about the no name brands out there. The last two tastings we’ve had winners that were kinda obscure. And believe me when I say that I am just as surprised as you. I fully expected Ciroc to win the vodka tasting and I was expecting one of the expensive brands to win this tasting. I’ve always loved to try new things and weird brands, and sure, sometimes it turns out bad. But what I think we are finding out is that, with a popular name brand, you’re not necessarily going to get a bad product but there are better products that don’t advertise and haven’t or don’t want to make a name for themselves. Now, this may not be true all across the board, but the point is don’t be afraid to look on the lower shelves for new possibly cheaper products that you might really enjoy.
